Last night I got to hear Joshua Onysko, the founder of Pangea Organics.
In some ways, Joshua is a standard-issue entrepreneur: curious, durable, ambitious, practical, experimental, relentless, result-seeking, a man in constant motion.
His career began with a book about soap. Joshua went to dinner with his mom and the book was just sitting there. So he made some. Just to see. (Entrepreneurs prize the art of the possible above the art of the profitable.) Joshua went off on a world tour, to India, Nepal, Tibet, Kashmir, Brooklyn, New Orleans. And then home to Wyoming where he made more soap. Another great loop: Oregon, Bellingham, Alaska, Yukon, Denver, Hong Kong, Macao, Tokyo, Thailand, Cambodia and then home to the same destination: soap. Eventually, with the help of IDEO, Joshua was producing the line of products called Pangea Organics.
People like Joshua are the shock troops of capitalism. They have a vision which they relentlessly turn into enterprise, into action, into a company that scales up. But to capture the full difficulty (and value) of what they do, we need a different metaphor. Entrepreneurs are the performance artists of capitalism. They do things the market has never seen before. And if they catch the moment, they can actually change the market. Joshua is doing that now.
Usually, this is where a Venture Capitalist (or large corporation) steps in and relieves the entrepreneur of his or her accomplishment. It's like that Roller Derby move where people pull upside you and lift you off the floor by your elbows. Your skates no longer touch the deck. The VC lavishes you with blandishments. He offers sums that take the breath away. All entrepreneurs say "no" at first. But the offers get larger and more dizzying. Until the entrepreneur says "geez, what's not to like. What could be wrong with having many millions of dollars and the rest of my life ahead of me?"
But Joshua is not interested in the usual life trajectory of the entrepreneur. No, he is intent on the reformation of capitalism. He wants to change the way we think about products, packaging, manufacture, retail, consumption, and the planet. (Some Pangea products have seeds embedded in the packaging…to make the garbage bloom.)
In a sense, Joshua is exercising the advantage of his generation. My generation (boomers) tend to see the world as a series of discrete episodes. What happens here doesn't have any necessary connection there. My generation can see consequences but we tend to think of them as capital letters joined by little arrows: A > B. It's clear that Joshua thinks more in terms of concatenation, where events run in all directions at once.
So Joshua turns out to be a double entrepreneur. He thinks about all the things that make up enteprise, all the things that have to happen for a start-up to start up. But this is merely "booster rocket one." Then he starts thinking about all the things the start-up can make happen beyond the narrow scope of its enterprise. This is concatenating capitalism, as ripples carry the influence of Pangea out into the larger world, our broader culture, changing how we do business, how we consume things, how we organize effort and outcome.
The event was organized by AIGA's Metro North. (To declare a conflict of interest, I should tell you that this chapter is organized by my wife, Pamela DeCesare.) The Metro North board took Joshua to dinner afterward. He said in passing that he's now looking for "patient capitalists." And I sat there thinking "Ok, now he's going to teach capital to dance to a new tune."
It is the genius of capitalism that it is so very pliable. It doesn't really care about the details, just so long as interested parties can engage in transactions that work to their respective advantage. Indeed, it has conventionally preserved that brilliant act of reduction that Adam Smith accomplished in Wealth of Nations. It removes from consideration everything extra-transactional, all the cultural, social, political, ecological factors coming in and going out of the transaction. All of these were, in Kuhnian terms, extra-paradigmatic. The model didn't include them. It didn't need to know about them. Onyesko and the double entrepreneurs appear now to be reinstalling these factors, making them visible, thinkable, calculable, perhaps even manageable. The world wrought by single entrepreneurs was pretty astonishing. The one being produced by Joshua Onysko and the new entrepreneurs is going to be very interesting indeed.
References
Kuhn, Thomas S. 1996. The Structure of Scientific Revolutions. 3rd ed. Chicago: University Of Chicago Press.
Thanks to Scott Lerman of the Metro North board, you can see Joshua's talk here.
Acknowledgments
Thanks to Cheryl Swanson of the AIGA Metro North board for organizing the talk.
Thanks to Amy Domini for several conversations which helped prepare me to understand Onysko's enterprise.
I have worked with Paula Rosch several times over the years. So when I sat down to think about who was acting in the capacity of an unspoken Chief Culture Officer, she came to mind.
I asked Paula if she would sit down and tell me about how she helped make Kimberly-Clark a living, breathing culture, and she produced this fascinating document. Here are some of the highlights that await you.
• Paula is the inventor on record for some 80 patents. We talk a lot about innovation these days, but not so much about innovators. They remain unsung heroes. Paula is one of these.
• Paula’s contribution to KC’s cultural knowledge came in part from her use of “Scouts.” Scouts, by Paula’s definition, are “behavior leaders who intuitively model new shifts in human behavior years and even decades before the mainstream population.” She looked at
“how [Scouts] lived their lives, using those observations to develop hypotheses and push them as far out as possible – allowing a lot of hang time in the abstract until the right insights and models come together to be translated into product, including serendipitous bits and pieces, all these merging together to hone in on the idea.”
• Wow, that’s my reaction. Wow and then some. Some part of the genius of good product development process is captured here. How we find new ideas and then hold them in a loose constellation until the right pattern can form. It’s a fantastically difficult process, this is. It’s a process of thinking everything all at once and “roughly” until some combination arrives to bring everything into sharp focus. Wonderful.
• But not always appreciated. K-C’s was a traditional culture. Sometimes creativity and culture was said to be “soft.” I have heard this from several unsung heroes. Those who don’t understand the process call it an impressionistic, intuitive, somehow female undertaking. Which means that the unsung hero has to do something very difficult in an environment that is sometimes laced with skepticism and sometimes hostility. Being creative in the presence of people who are resistant, this is one of the double binds that confronts the culture creative, the CCO.
• But at some level KC knew it needed Paula and people like her. It was a company in transition, moving from a paper to a consumer products company. It is impossible to climb this hierarchy from functional products to richer value propositions without cultural advice. And that’s where Paula came in.
• The still larger context is the business model that the corporation had created for itself. And as Paula notes, this was something dedicated to creating a few, massively successful products. These days we are seeing some corporations generate many, smaller offerings in order to see what works in an inscrutable world. (“Fail early, fail often to succeed big” being the new mantra for some.) And this new model is I think more responsive to the spirit of creativity that Paula brings to the corporation. Paula also experienced a siloed KC, and here too there are new models of the corporation promise to make the corporation more porous and more participative.
• Paula notes the sensation many of us have when we return from a culture seeking (Paula’s “Scouting”) expedition.
“There is a huge universe of behaviors, practices, beliefs, insights, and attitudes – human culture – but only a small percentage of them are allowed inside the corporate doors, usually not the most portentous ones but the most easily workable. I remember I would be so exhilarated when I would do innovative consumer or Scout research – anything was possible, until I re-entered the cement atrium of the corporate building, understood the challenges of selling new insights, and felt the air leak out before I passed the security desk."
• Finally, Paula changed the culture at KC. People there now routinely use language, processes and techniques she introduced. And she continues to serve as a valued consultant. But she didn’t stay. And this is surely one of the most urgent orders of business before the corporation now. How to recruit people like Paula, and when you are lucky to come upon someone of her extraordinary talents, make her a permanent, honored member of the corporation. I think people like Paula were once the badge of a corporation that was making an effort, taking a risk. I think it’s fair to say she is now as essential to those who serve in marketing, finance and technology. You have to have a Paula, and this means doing whatever it takes to keep her. She is the new face of the living, breathing corporation. And if you have a “Paula” as good as Paula, well, dude, move heaven and earth to keep her.
So, without further ado, I give you Paula’s characteristically illuminating answers to the questions I sent her. Good reading!
Note: I left K-C in January of 2001, so my notes represent my experiences there from 1978-2000.
1) What was your role at Kimberly-Clark?
a) I was a product developer for 22 years, the first few years as the consumer needs champion on teams that developed and introduced improvements to HUGGIES® diapers.
I was fortunate to have a special assignment not long into my career – that of developing K-C’s first Innovation Fair. Research and Engineering had a year-old program called “Innovation Time”, allowing individuals the time to work on new ideas that might be good for the company but were outside their specific assignments. The Innovation Fair rounded up these ideas and presented them to potential sponsors.
I mention this because this was a pivotal learning opportunity for me. Developing the Fair – a “product” in itself – and helping the participants to pull prototypes and communications together for an audience, just jumping in to this effort and figuring it out as we went along, taught and prepared me more for product development and entrepreneurism than any other experience.
I spent the rest of my K-C career in advanced product development or new business identification, usually as a team leader, and sometimes as what Gifford Pinchot called an “Intrapreneur” – a corporate entrepreneur, driving new products from discovery to basis-for-interest to commercialization. It’s the nature of many companies to prematurely dismiss ideas that represent what the world might want/need 5, 10 years out and beyond in favor of near-term opportunities – the intrapreneur stays under the radar, using passion, brains, intuition, stealth, any and every other human and material resource available to keep things moving. It helps to have had some managers that often looked the other way.
Many years ago, Rose Moss, a good friend and associate of mine (www.rosemosswriter.com), gave me a wonderful expression for the nurturing of new product concepts: “Socialize the idea.” This is the perfect mantra for the Intrapreneur. Like an infant, one initially shields and protects the idea, exposing it gradually and appropriately so the world begins to know it and it begins to know the world, and they begin to accept each other.
b) During the years I was at K-C, the company went through a transformation from paper company to consumer products company (see Good to Great by Jim Collins). These were great times for learning and redefining (for example, the role of consumer advocate and product developer had been relatively undefined. I got to assist with this effort. There were product developers there older than I who just “got it” and did it, without acclaim. These are my own role models and unsung heroes). The frustration of this transformation came in trying to move beyond an objective, manufacturing mindset into a more subjective, applied consumer view. It was easy for some to make this leap, more difficult for others. But this is where I began to carve a niche for myself.
c) More than any other category, my work in the Infant Care category had the most significant impact on the company. Early on, I provided the product development and consumer leadership for the introduction of HUGGIES diaper improvements. Later, with my teams, I conceived and championed the development of HUGGIES Baby Steps, Huggies Supreme, and Huggies Storytime® disposable diapers, Huggies Little Swimmers® disposable swim pants, and Good-Nites® sleep shorts. I am the inventor-on-record for nearly 80 patents for these products (as well as other branded K-C products).
My job assignments as new product team leader were broad. For example, “Identify a new-to-the-world product for the infant or child care categories.” The vision, research strategy, and process largely were up to me and my co-workers.
I always started with a practice of articulating a new, divergent frame of reference for looking at the problem. Talking with and observing people, particularly behavior leaders (Scouts) and how they lived their lives, using those observations to develop hypotheses and push them as far out as possible – allowing a lot of hang time in the abstract until the right insights and models come together to be translated into product, including serendipitous bits and pieces, all these merging together to hone in on the idea.
I was fortunate in that I was able to establish some credibility early on, with successful product improvement work and the Innovation Fair, and acquired the sponsorship of some senior management, which brought me a lot of freedom not often allocated to someone in my position.
2) What were some of your favorite accomplishments?
a) The incredible network of diverse, brilliant, creative individuals that has been my privilege to meet and work with, inside and outside the company. Not my accomplishment, but certainly my favorite.
b) Participation and leadership in the definition of the Role of Product Developer.
c) That, beyond new product introductions, we – the circles of insightful people with whom I worked – actually did change the culture within, changing the processes by which we uncovered new opportunities and developed them. And we changed the language. I am not sure how well the insights underscoring these changes are understood, but it is rewarding to see the influence.
d) Huggies Little Swimmers was my favorite “intrapreneurial” effort. While it was off strategy for corporate new products because it addressed an existing category rather than new-to-the-world, I was able to find senior level sponsorship for the idea with the personal care sector. I had passion for the concept, so I moved along with the project. I had senior support and budget now, but a team of only two, including myself. So we launched what I call Stone Soup product development – make what you are doing stimulating, fun and worthwhile so people are excited to get involved. Again, many people looked to make a creative contribution. They needed to be shown appreciation and respect for the effort.
We did have an item – a very cool foam pen that represented the project logo – that became a badge of honor that you were part of the work. So interesting – people yearn for creative involvement.
What was a team of two became an unofficial team of probably 50 or more, all of whom played a huge role in the success of what became a new business that met K-C’s challenging requirements in size and profitability. As for their managers – they made a point of ignoring that some of their deputies’ time was getting sucked away for Little Swimmers (senior level support and endorsement is critical for new product development – it keeps doors open). And working with babies who were finally had a garment that would allow them entrance into public swimming pools – parents with babies back then will understand)… Just too much fun.
e) The Development of the Scout behavior philosophy, especially as applied to new personal care products. This was the greatest opportunity I had to really use my Scout and behavioral innovation processes in very deep ways. The result was a new product line that was never developed – too different than the normal corporate brands in concept and manufacturing – but that offered the broadest, highest tests scores seen in the personal care products industry until that time.
3) Tell me something about what I am assuming was an engineering, male, Midwestern culture inside K-C while you were there. What were your observations?
a) First of all, like many companies, K-C was large enough to have several sub-cultures. Rather than “engineering” and “male” (I knew and depended on many innovative engineers and men!), I think a homogeneous, linear thinking culture focused primarily on the bottom line best describes the operating culture I knew. Some might object, but I am speaking from a creative’s perspective. Some observations I had about the culture at different points in my career?
• That there was a low threshold for and buy-in to diverse and alternative thinking.
• That “creative” means frivolous and feminine, even when its results are delivering millions a year in operating profits.
• That hiring/promoting the familiar can produce a homogeneous environment and philosophy (and in this case, representative of Midwest culture you mention).
• That personal creative excellence, intuition, chutzpa and passion often translate into “management problem”.
• That the culture, while it tolerates the alternative and creative mindset, it doesn’t embrace the richness of opportunities it can offer.
These were generally the positions of some who might have felt threatened by processes they weren’t comfortable with. BUT, I worked with scores of people who intuitively recognized good ideas and knocked themselves out to be involved and make them successful, whether they were officially on the team or not. There is a human drive to be creative and people want to be involved. You do need to remember to say “thank you.”
b) Part of the Fortune 500 culture was the commonplace objective that each new product needed to deliver at least $100 million in manufacturer’s sales. Being able to manufacture it on existing assets was also an common, unspoken criteria (if the objective didn't start out this way, it became a key consideration once the opportunity was defined). Smaller and niche opportunities were discouraged, even if they delivered a high level of operating profits. New processes and machines were risky – what if the business failed? Some new businesses did fail, and if clearly understanding the reasons is not always pursued to its fullest extent, the fear of new business risk remains intact.
c) The Midwest culture – along with fewer women in the professional workplace in my early years – also impacted who led projects and how the marketplace was viewed. Interestingly, when I started at KC, most of the product developers and decision makers in the Feminine Care department were men. They developed a product that met the needs of many women, but called it the Kotex® Heavy Duty Tampon – why not just call it the Die-hard battery of tampons! Try finding a woman to put that on the grocery conveyer!
4) What were some of the frustrations you experienced during your career at K-C?
a) I think I shared a huge frustration with others: that there was a threshold of tolerance for creative insight and expertise beyond which one’s observations and ideas are dismissed as insignificant and even non-essential. There is a huge universe of behaviors, practices, beliefs, insights, and attitudes – consumer culture – but only a small percentage of them get inside the corporate doors, usually not the most portentous ones but the most easily workable. This actually became more common later in my career. I would feel exhilarated after doing innovative consumer or Scout research – anything was possible, until I re-entered the cement atrium of the corporate building, understood the challenges of selling new insights, and felt the air leak out before I passed the security desk.
b) Secrecy, in communications both outside and within the company. It just shuts down intellectual and creative transfer of any kind, and sets up mistrust. c) The role and function of Product Developer: this was an undefined role in my early years. Product developers had been typically under-valued because managers “don’t know what they do so we don’t know how to evaluate them.” It was a handful of product developers in the early 80’s, myself included, who took on the job of defining the role and determining the performance parameters, using as case studies how the successful entries of products like Huggies were actually products of insights into consumer behavior and intuitive design, in addition to the materials and engineering skill. This effort morphed into a corporate product development training program that became a model for the other disciplines in the corporation. Product Development suddenly was the cool job to have. We developed our own identity as Product Developers and gained intellectual influence and personal and professional identity with it. So this frustration was turned into a happy ending, a group accomplishment of which I am very proud.
d) After successfully developing Little Swimmers by begging and borrowing and luring help, it set the expectation that I should do that for my next project. Somehow I had gained the tag of “individual contributor”, most likely because I worked without an official team on Little Swimmers. But if teams were being provided for other projects, why not to mine? I once heard an interview with film director Robert Altman on NPR – that each time he produced and succeeded, the critical bar was set higher and the expectations for his next project were raised. Although I don’t pretend to be in his creative league, his comments struck home. But as usual, I managed to round up a project posse.
As a senior product developer, and in the role of “intrapreneur” on Little Swimmers, I wore all the hats, technical and consumer, including hand-making many of the prototypes, making test product in machiladoras in July, performing materials testing, as well as the concept and positioning development work, consumer evaluations, whatever it took, taking the product through quantitative and volumetric concept-and-use testing and Basis For Interest. When it came time for evaluations, the senior technical people who were my peers (PhD “Fellows”) did not regard the work as technically sophisticated enough for recognition or promotion in those ranks. Since I was working for a senior business manager on the project, I didn’t have a technical champion for support. I was caught in the middle.
There was simply no career path for the very senior level, creative, prolifically successful entrepreneurial product developer with a broad consumer-culture view. Business and Technical management were inappropriate (too right brained for me and actually took one out of the product development role), nor was the Fellow path appropriate (more for the highly technical). I didn’t fit either path (this was true for other senior level product developers). If my unique – and successful – methodologies and insights had been met with a broader willingness to understand, that might have offered some sense of fulfillment.
e) The silos of R&D and of Marketing.
5) Favorite inspirations
a) Buckminster Fuller, particularly in the book, The Best of Friends. In describing his friendship with Japanese sculptor Isamu Noguchi, he used his same theories of geodesic dome construction, and set me off on the value and practice of triangular and 3D thinking in so much of my work. Kleenex Ultra facial tissue was a direct result of this influence.
b) My “super” Scout network. For their ability to let go of convention and be innovators and agents of real behavioral change.
c) People-watching in general, including eavesdropping. Just trying to observe without mixing myself up in the situation. The best source of inspiration and ideas.
d) Dan Endres – one of my unsung heroes at KC, who retired several years before I left K-C. He was a passionate pioneer and advocate for environmentally sustainable products and practices, and an outstanding product developer. I had good supporters, but Dan was my only true mentor.
e) Great natural beauty – big water and big mountains – the most inspirational, developmental, and productive conversations I have had were during walks near water and mountains.
f) The New York Times. I’ve read it every day for decades. Every day I find something to use or store away for later when I need a missing piece.
g) Street wandering throughout the world.
h) My Uncle Art – I was totally intrigued by his behavior and interests and somehow understood him as a “Scout” even when I was a kid – though I didn’t have a word for it then. But he became the platform for the theory.
i) Julia Child (and the diverse food universe in general) – her trilling voice commanding “Saaave the juices!” taught me that any little detail can eventually be the missing piece to the puzzle. It’s all good.
j) My husband Frank and his passion for innovators in music, literature, sports – culture!
6) What were some of your strategies and tactics?
a) After a few project successes, they begin to think that you might be on to something!
b) Personal traits – I was well-liked, had a sense of humor, appreciated and recognized people’s help, had vision and passion which transferred to the teams I belonged to.
c) I did stay under the radar. My bosses always knew I was doing some kind of research, some of it “stealth” research. I was selective about what I reported, but always reported relevant progress (“Socialize the idea!”). By the time it was “safe” to lay out the vision/product, I was pretty far along and had a good amount of data.
d) The company never understood Scouts, just that I used them, who and whatever they were. Going off to Seattle, Cambridge, etc., doing research, ideations and workshops with Scouts (both consumer Scouts and my “super” Scout network), etc., gave me the environment and companionship I needed to pull visions and opportunities together. While it was often a challenge to communicate insights when I went back, I always returned with stronger vision, direction, and motivation.
e) I walked the walk. The subjects I talked about, the books I read, the people I came to know, the experiences I sought in my personal life, all had the trappings of “future”. So it made some sense that I might be the one to understand the future.
f) I filled my office with products, pictures, packages, prototypes, everything that could relate to the project and from which I could draw inspiration and connections. But that also encouraged people to stop in and talk, check out what I was doing, and share some ideas. When I was working on personal care products, people would stop by the door just because it smelled so good – product buy-in via aromatherapy! Stone Soup product development.
g) I had faith in my own unique abilities. I focused on what I saw was happening to people and their lives, and translated that into good products. In the end, I left because I couldn’t bring in as much of the outside culture as I wanted. I wanted to do more of it, trying to capture as much of the outside culture as I could, with as many categories as I could, push my own capabilities.
7) Final Thoughts
I am not sure that companies should recruit and keep individuals like a Paula Rosch. Perhaps individuals like me belong on the outside of corporations. I found my corporate career accomplishments and experiences immensely satisfying, but I do enjoy operating in my current, broader environment. I may be even more effective, bringing a breadth of consumer culture insights to a diverse group of clients who somehow mix it all up and create something more unique than if they had followed an internally resourced program. I hope so.
___________________________
For more information about Paula or to get in touch with her, see her website "Paula Rosch, Ideas that Grow" here.
"Did you know the Pittsburgh Pirates are the worst team in Christendom?
"Really!"
The new way of saying "really?" means (roughly),
"That's what you're going with? I wouldn't have made that choice. I wonder if you're an idiot."
As in:
"I'm thinking about moving to Connecticut."
"Really."
The first really is using spoken with the upward lilt of a question. The second really usually comes with an emphatic downturn in tone. (It's heavy with scorn.)
I'm not sure when this new really arrived. Certainly, a tipping point came when Saturday Night Live began running "Really?!? with Seth and Amy." Phrases dream of this kind of exposure. To be blessed by Lorne Michaels. To be lifted out of the obscurity. "Really" went big time.
But it's not enough to be elevated by Lorne Michaels. A phrase doesn't flourish unless it speaks to something in our culture. And that's the question: what does the sudden popularity of this little phrase tell us about ourselves?
Well, certainly, it's a way of saying "you're a moron" without have to actually say "you're a moron." But this isn't new. Americans are always eager to pass judgment on one another's intelligence. Especially if they can do so without provoking a brawl.
The new really doesn't just judge the speakers' intelligence but also their judgment. As in, "I saw what you did there and frankly…" This carries with it the still deeper implication, one that says, "We are all working from the same rule book. So I know the options you had at your disposal. And, frankly, you choose badly."
And this raises an interesting possibility: that we are moving to a different kind of social order. (I just know someone is going to leave a one word comment to this post: Really.) Are we moving from a "first-really" to a "second-really" society.
In the "first-really society," we expect other people to be surprising, perhaps even inscrutable. We don't know what they are thinking. We don't presume to know their options or to second-guess their choices. This is because in the first-really society, we don't share a rule book. We may have a rough idea of what others are thinking, but not much more.
The US has traditionally been a first-really society. Because Americans have always been diverse, it's tough to make assumptions about who the other is. Americans are pleased to be credulous. We are happy when astonished. This is part of the point of the exercise, part of the pleasure of living in a world that is dedictated to experiment, audacity, and dynamism. You just never really know. Americans are more interested in authenticity and spontaneity. A first-really world suits us.
In a second-really society, people are scrutable. Traditionally, second-really societies are ritualized, hierarchical, court societies. Everyone knows the rules of the social game. They are watching one another play their assigned parts. Everyone's "on the same page." Britain has always been a "first-really" world, especially when compared to the US. In most social situations, the British are in a position to second-guess a social choice. (But, of course, they do not say "really." They only think it.)
So the question is this: is the US moving from being a first-really society to a second-really society? Is it moving from a place that is reckless in its curiosity and credulity to one that is much more mapped and scrutable? Is this US a more knowledgable, shareable social world? Perhaps we now more alike, better able see the choices others make and pass judgment.
I will leave it to readers to weigh in on why this might be. Here are a couple of possibilities:
1) that our absolute sense of expansion is diminishing. Frontiers, most of them anyhow, are disappearing. We are losing the sense of America as a place that grows boundlessly and recklessly. The rise of China and India takes away America's heavy-weight crown as the most ferociously expansive economy. Except in the digital domain, Americans feels like a more scrutable place. Maybe. (I'm trying this one on.)
2) that America is less diverse from an immigration point of view. Our strangers are less strange to us. We can made assumptions about a shared rule book.
3) that Millennials, to the extent one can generalize, were perhaps more completely socialized than previously generations. It's possible that they have a rule book previous generations did not. Boomers and Gen Xers both cultivated a sense of the wilderness of the world. (Very different wildernesses, to be sure.)
4) that everyone is better at culture, more nimble, better at empathy, less alarmed by difference. We are citizens of many worlds. We do not share a single rule book. We have access to many rule books.
Your thoughts, please.
References
See Seth Myer and Amy Poehler on Saturday Night Live here.
Anthropological dreams are made of this: helping Disney and Marvel manage their rapprochement.
Nothing short of heroic effort will do. Disney is, after all, a pretty good marker for all that is mainstream about American culture. Marvel is, by deliberate contrast, darker and less predictable. One corporation turns in towards the gravitational center of our culture. The other prefers to plot a course for the margin, for the uncharted, for the unknown. I mean, this can't be a match made in heaven. It's going to be tricky, complicated and, possibly, agonizing.
Right?
No, actually. Stan Lee, god of the comix world, says the "synergy" between the two companies is "perfect." And The Economist says a clash of cultures is unlikely.
Disney is no longer the control freak it was under its former boss, Michael Eisner. His successor, Bob Iger, has turned out to be a relatively hands-off boss, with the Pixar acquisition a model of the sort of treatment Marvel can expect.
Hmm. I wonder if it's not too soon to go leaping to conclusions. It may well be true that Disney and Marvel will not suffer cultural differences of the big C kind. The center-periphery distinction matters less and less. Both parties have decoded the other. So Disney and Marvel may occupy different cultural trajectories, but they need not be prisoners of their strengths. What will vex and potentially undo this marriage is not the culture "out there," and their relative locations in our culture. It's the culture "in there."
This is culture of the little "c" variety, the ones that define the corporate culture. These are subtle and powerfully different. Some are merely "tomato" and I say "tomaato," that sort of thing. But others are fundamental differences of concept and problem solving. These sound little but in the press of everyday work, they add up and occasionally tip over. The difference between the two corporate culture is a little like the differences between the operating system of a PC and Apple. Not so very different, but when you are working on the fly annoying as the dickens, and sometimes just completely wrongfooting.
The differences of the corporate culture are subtle and deeply embedded. Indeed they are so deeply buried they are impossible to see. You cannot see them just by looking, anymore than you can work out the grammar of a speech just by speaking.
No, the thing to do is send in a team for anthropologist who will dig out these assumptions, logics and subroutines (to say nothing of the mixed metaphors) and (wait for it) build a translation table for the two companies.
Think of us as ferrets, but think of us. Tom Guarriello, Mary Walker, Steve Portigal, Cheryl Swanson (for all of whom I speak without permission), and yours truly are standing by.
References
Anonymous. 2009. Of mouse and X-Men. The Economist. September5-11. p. 71.
There are many apps for Twitter (Seesmic, etc.), but Tweetie is a thing of beauty. As Brian Chen says,
Tweetie's interface is so clean you would think it came straight out of Apple headquarters.
The Windows world is clamoring for a PC Windows version of Tweetie, but it doesn't look its going to get one. When Chen ask Loren Brichter about it, he said.
I’m a Mac and iPhone kind of guy, so probably not. My philosophy has always been to build things that I would use myself. If I start using Windows,or Linux or Android or the Pre for that matter, on a day-to-day basis, then yes, I’ll absolutely want to bring Tweetie over to those platforms. Chances look slim though.
I wonder if this is culturally telling. In another time, a guy like Brichter might be expected to pursue the Windows market. That was name of the game. Maximize your audience. Grow the business. Scale up. Cash out.
It wasn't just the name of the game. It's the very logic, the deep presumption, of capitalism. You were in it to win it. The point of the exercise was to seize and then exploit opportunity.
But Loren sings a different song. It sounds like he's happy to work to the limit of the world he cares about…and no farther. He builds things he will use himself…and not otherwise. It would take an extended interview to capture his motives in full. (And it may just be that he does want to have to program for the Windows world. And who could blame him for that?) But it may be that he doesn't care about growth. He is not looking for economic triumph. He is looking for sufficiency.
Will we see more of this? I think we might. We have a generation or two in place who are not much interested in the individualism that is red of tooth and claw. They are happy to do well, but not less interested in "succeeding wildly." They are looking perhaps for that sweet spot between too little and too much, between the privations that forces you to live at the bottom of Maslow's hierarchy and the surfeit of wealth that forces you to worry about how big the yacht should be.
Well, we have had people who entertained this view for many years (and many generations). I am wondering whether this group is growing. Is this position less minor and more major? Does it now have a shot it someday become the majority opinion? This is where anthropology is obliged to hand things over to sociology.
As people seek intrinsic rewards over extrinsic rewards, this trend must grow. After all, programming for Windows will take almost all the pleasure out of Brichter's work. He will make much more money, but the cost will be high. And that is surely one of the shifts going on here. People like Brichter are measuring career objectives in a more complicated way, not just by wealth, but by satisfaction, bliss, colorful parachutes and other metrics.
But there may also be a new idea of scale here. "Good enough" and "just enough" are ideas we see breaking out all over. Perhaps they are career and business objectives as well. There is something happening here. Or not. What do you think?
References
Chen, Brian X. 2009. Hands-on: Tweetie for Mac Shakes up Twitterverse. Wired. April 20, 2009. here.
Acknowledgments
Thanks to Craig Swanson for telling me about Tweetie.
I spend the day in a room with the senior managers of a mid size company.
It was interesting to see how many of their problems are not paradigmatic problems: issues you can get to the bottom of with due diligence, the right data, the application of hard thinking, and the customary approach.
No, many of the problems these people are dealing with have an air of indeterminacy. This is pre or post paradigmatic thinking. It's hard to know exactly what the problem is. It's tough to know which terms apply, how best to frame the issues, what the best perspective is. In other words, this is not processual thinking. This is developmentl, demanding, and entirely intellectual.
And poof, goes that favorite distinction between theory and application. This work in industry is abstract, self scrutinizing, reflexive and foundational. And this says, I think, that industry thinkers have an urgent need to the calm and resources of an academic setting. They need moments of problem solving when they don't need to have an answer by the end of the business day. They need to practice a little more intellectual "catch and release," when you form ideas and throw them back to see if they will ever return as plausible solutions. They need to canvass their options more widely.
What they need is a sabbatical. If youth is wasted on the young, sabbaticals are wasted on the academic. I don't doubt that academics need them. But I do think that industry types need them just as much, perhaps more. The university needs to see these executives as their own Haley's comets, people who pass through the university world every 3 or 5 or 7 years before setting off again for another lap in the deep space of managerial experience.
When does some university step up and make this possible? This is a huge opportunity to change the fundamentals of executive education. It is also a possibility to recruit a new group of alums.
When does some corporation step up and make this possible? As it is, every corporation is dangerously close to burning through its human capital as a result of over use and the failure to give respite. When you think about how expensive it is to find the right person, to make them a full and useful member of the corporation, surely a sabbatical investment is merely good sense.
But this is about something more than just protecting the resources of corporation. It is also part of the process of equipping the corporation with people who have the resources and presence of mind to wrestle well with the most pressing problems at hand. What's it worth when senior managers making their most important distinctions better?
In March, the network had scored its 11th straight quarter as the nation's top-rated cable outlet—averaging 3.2 million viewers in prime time, the biggest audience ever in cable. (Johnnie Roberts, Newsweek, ref. below)
Every parent company wants a child like this.
Of all NBCU's properties, including the namesake broadcaster NBC and its Universal studio, USA has become the biggest earner, delivering roughly $1 billion in profits last year.
This can't happen without someone smart and creative in charge. That someone is Bonnie Hammer.
Since [Hammer] took over in 2004, USA has produced a string of hits: Burn Notice, about a spy who's been fired; Psych, about a crime-solving police consultant who pretends to be psychic; In Plain Sight, focusing on a U.S. marshal aiding people in the witness-protection program.
Hammer's success raises an urgent question: how in the dickens does she do it? TV is littered with failures. Hammer appears to be batting around .800. What's the secret?
The great thing about Hammer is that she actually has an answer. An lot of creatives demur, giving us answers that are vague and self celebrating: "Oh, it just comes to me," or "What can I say, pure intuition!"
Not Bonnie Hammer. She knows how she does it. And she's prepared to say how she does it. Good news for the anthropology. Hammer has put her creative process under glass. It's our job to see if we can divine the Hammer grammer.
In his excellent Newsweek article, Johnnie Roberts says,
Before Hammer's arrival, USA was the television equivalent of a potluck supper, a hodgepodge of reruns and castoffs. Driven by her unique show-selection technique—a process she refers to as the "brand filter"—USA has been transformed into a cohesive collection of character-driven shows that are resonating with viewers, and advertisers are in hot pursuit. […] The USA tag line describes its strategy: "Characters Welcome."
Hammer's secret, then, is "brand filter." And what is this, exactly? Roberts says,
Today when considering scripts, Hammer and her team ask a routinized series of questions: Does the show have a fun sensibility? Does it have a "blue sky" tone of hopefulness? Does it revolve around an "aspirational," if quirky, lead character with a moral and ethical center? Potential shows are scored based on how closely they match these dictates; only high scorers make it on air.
The USA show Monk was already in place when Hammer arrived. And we can guess that it gave Hammer a precedent and a guideline for that "quirky, lead character." Monk helped to expand what counted as quirky on TV. Shaloub's character is not merely "colorful." He is afflicted, irritating even when endearing. Monk gave Hammer room to work.
The Burn Notice character is trapped in a limbo, dependent on a friend, a girlfriend, and his mother. This "quirky" departs nicely from the steely eyed, iron jawed model of competence that TV espionage prefers. The Psych character is an early Jerry Lewis with a brain, an intertextual trickster who japes and goofs. His "quirky" is kinetic, hyperactive tom foolery. In In Plain Sight, the hero is, by turns, grouchy, rueful, and imperious. This quirky charts new ground for a female lead. Monk made many things possible. Hammer is exploring the options.
Notice how unthreatening Hammer'squirky is. I was in Saratoga this summer with friends (thank you, Craig and Cheryl Swanson), and we were accosted by a small, energetic man who shouted historical declarations and theatrical possibilities at us. Our first reaction to fear for our lives…and then our wallets. Eventually, we saw this guy was no threat to anyone. "What a character." someone said. "Character" is what we call people who are odd but not dangerous. Hammer keeps quirky civilized.
There's a second way Hammer manages quirkiness. Her characters are never exposed to real peril or emotional darkness. Despair is not allowed at USA Networks. This is the oldest bargain in American television, but it has been challenged recently by shows like The Wire and The Sarah Connor Chronicles. Hammer will have none of it. Thus does her " blue sky" condition operate to keep her "Monk" license kept from running amuck (amonk).
"Fun sensibility" feels a little vaque. All of Hammer's shows have this sensibility, but they depart so thoroughly, it's hard to know exactly what fun sensibility is. Perhaps, this too is a boundary condition. It says that while Hammer and company are attending to other matters, they must be careful not to compromise the entertainment value of the project. It guarantees, a certain animation or froth that "keeps the thing light." Perhaps what fun delivers is fresh.
On the last two qualities, the moral and the aspirational, I'm less clear. Does "aspirational" mean that we want to be like these characters? Does it mean that these character aspire to something else in life?
It seems to me these character are a little anti-aspirational. They seem to me to endure a certain status immobility. They are content with their place in life. Naturally, they work their allowance. They occupy their worlds with a certain intensity. There is lots here that is "excess to requirement," but nothing that resists, protests or looks to transcend their lot in life. Perhaps I'm missing what is meant by "aspirational."
On the moral center, I'm still less clear. Monk is so preoccupied with his own special code that morality doesn't seem to have much to do with it. The Burn Notice guy seeks justice for himself. Other kinds of justice come a distant second. The In Plain Sight hero pursues a private morality, and the Psych character couldn't care less. But again, perhaps I'm missing something.
There are things about Hammer hits that are not anticipated in her code. In Plain Sight makes a playground of the tensions and ambivalences of witness relocation. There is also a dysfunctional family played really well by Leslie Ann Warren, Nichole Hiltz, Cristian de la Fuente and work life played really well by by Fred Weller and Paul Ben-Victor. These together with the remarkable Mary McCormick give In Plain Sight a richness that makes The Closer look increasingly palid. I am not sure what we would need to add to the Hammer grammer but let's leave that for the moment.
Psych really is all about the cultural referencing. As I argue in Chief Culture Officer, popular culture was once thoroughly cowed. It was low culture and it knew it was low culture. Quoting that was for high culture, for the arts and letters, for serious people doing lofty things. I'm not sure when this changed but now popular culture routinely references itself. Consider Buffy, the Vampire Slayer, The Simpsons, NCIS, ESPN Sportscenter, to name a few.
The Psych guy has turned the subreference from an aside into the very source of the dynamism of the show. Otherwise, Psych is exceedingly thin, a boys own, Hardy Boys adventure with not very much to show for itself. Perhaps intertextuality, to give it its fancy name, needs a higher profile in the Hammer grammer.
Burn notice is interesting, I think, because we watch the character struggle with a world that it disorderly and uncontrollable. His fate is being decided by forces and people larger than himself. But in every episode, he finds away to overcome by "tacking" together friends and family. He is a kind of a social McGyver (even as he acts as a technical McGyver as well). This collaboration doesn't do anything to reconcile him to his girl friend and mother. These relationships remain "spring loaded."
The Hammer grammer or brand filter calls for characters who are quirky. Thus does she explore the new latitude, or plenitude of our culture. It also calls for a blue sky condition and a fun sensibility. Thus does she manage quirky and prevent it from going places TV still generally does not go. Finally, Hammer aims for character made engaging by their aspirational and moral qualities.
This gives us a useful grammer for making culture. But as we have seen, there are a couple of other things that Hammer appears to be doing but not acknowledging. At the risk of presuming, we might add to the Hammer grammer the following: intertexuality, springloaded relationships, social richochet, a feeling of unpredictableness, plus a big dollop of great writing and great writing. There is also wit and cunning at work. (In one episode of In Plain Sight, the office staff gives an impromptu party for Mary to celebrate her engagement. My wife noticed that one of the balloons in the back ground read "Get Well Soon.") All of these need to be factored into our grammer. I mention them almost in passing. If I weren't sitting in a hotel room, I would dwell more carefully.
Grammars are like algorithms. We need to test them, test them and test them. More data, more editing. More data, more refinement. But clearly Hammer is closing in on a way to think about what works on TV, and our culture. More to the point, she is demonstrating with hit after hit that this is not some mere academic imagining. These ideas work. The grammer is refining.
References
McCracken, Grant. 2009. Chief Culture Officer. New York: Basic Books. Available for preorder at Amazon.com here.
Roberts, Johnnie L. 2009. Bonnie Hammer's Hit Factory: Inside USA Network's winning streak. Newsweek. July 11, 2009. here.
Thanks to Kenn Taylor for giving me the head's up on Roberts' excellent article.
I've been corresponding with Dave McCaughan of McCann Erickson Japan. We have been talking about the "gift economy."
As I understand it, the "gift economy" ideas says that we are moving away from direct exchange to something more circular.
Instead of trading "exactly this" for "exactly that," we now release things into the world (blog posts like this one, tweets, music, Youtube videos) with the hope that something will return to us someday in the form of some kind of value (revenue, reputation, social capital, cultural capital.) In other words, we gift the world with our efforts, and we do so without expectation or guarantee of a return. Adam Smith would be horrified.
I like this idea and what's more I believe in it. But it's not without its problems.
Take the case of Jimmy Pantino. He's spending his summer working at Denny's as a short order cook. He would much rather have spent it shooting and editing shorts for YouTube. He's got pretty good at it. The trouble is YouTube doesn't pay him anything. Nor do any of the 120,238 people who have seen his work on line. In point of fact, at least from Jimmy's point of view, this is not a gift economy. It's a grab economy, which is to say, no economy at all.
The problem is not that people don't want to pay Jimmy and free him from his Denny's bondage. They just don't want to pay him in the usual domination. In our economy, in most circumstances, the smallest useful unit of payment is a dollar. And we don't want to pay Jimmy a dollar. It's just too much. But we are prepared to pay him a nickle. And at a nickle a hit, Jimmy's YouTube audience would have paid him around $6000. This is not a princely sum. No, as an alternative to working this summer at Denny's, it's actually much richer than that.
The further problem is that there isn't any financial architecture that makes it possible for us to pay Jimmy his nickle. Certainly, there's no way to do it easily and swiftly. Not only do we not want to pay Jimmy a dollar. We really don't want to make a big production of it. Unless it happens in the blink of an eye, we can't be bothered. Which is to say, we want to spend as little in time as we do in money. (What is the temporal equivalent of a nickle? Two seconds, probably. Click of a mouse.)
What we need is a financial system capable of delivering fractional amounts in a frictionless way. When looking at one of Jimmy's videos we that they can just hit a button and keep going. No signing in or keeping track. Jimmy gets a nickle. We fill up our virtual wallet every quarter or so, distributing fractional amounts til it's gone.
The company that creates this system gets to be a hero to the kids. (Expect abject worship from Jimmy in particular.) It gets to be a participant in the new social networks and the plenitude of contemporary culture. It gets to be a patron of the new society and culture now in the works. Most simply, it gets to escape its status as an old order corporation and become a new order one. Tactically, this is a seat at the most important table. Strategically, its a chance to own some part of the future instead of tagging witlessly along behind it.
The person who does it gets to be the next Jeff Bezos or Jimmy Wales. You will be interviewed by Wired Magazine. You will be showered with honorary degrees. Most important: You will get way better seats at basketball games.
Building a system like this must be complicated. Otherwise we would have one by now. But surely it's not more complicated than Facebook. It just has to be a little more secure. Ok, a lot more secure. (I would love to hear from someone who has an idea of what this sort of system would require from a technical point of view.)
My plea: let's put the gift back into the gift economy, and for that matter, the economy in the economy. I mean, imagine what Jimmy Pantino could do for our culture if he was working with more than his free time and that crappy old computer his parents refuse to replace.
Economies create great things. Let's turn this one loose.
References
Mauss, Marcel. 2000. The Gift: The Form and Reason for Exchange in Archaic Societies. Reissue. New York: W.W. Norton & Co.
Sahlins, Marshall. 1972. Stone Age Economics. Aldine Transaction.
John Mackey, the CEO of Whole Foods, criticized Obama's approach to health care, and called for a private sector approach.
Let's do the cultural math and establish how Mackey damaged the brand and took money out of share holder's pockets.
1) Whole Foods is part of a larger food revolution.
2) the food revolution is part of a larger cultural revolution/social movement.
3) this revolution seeks a "kinder, gentler" universe in which the individual is less exposed to randomness and cruelty.
4) health care reform is designed to make the world less random and cruel. That's what Obama's reforms are for.
5) he who attacks this health reform movement attacks the "kinder, gentler" proposition.
5) he who attacks the "kinder, gentler" proposition attacks the cultural revolution/social movement.
6) he who attacks the cultural revolution/social movement attacks the food revolution.
7) he who attacks the food revolution attacks Whole Foods.
And so it follows that when Mackey offered his opinions, he inflicted damage on the brand and the share holder. If only he had a Chief Culture Officer.
References
Mackey, John. 2009. Op Ed Essay. Wall Street Journal. Aug. 12.
McCracken, Grant. 2009. Chief Culture Officer. New York: Basic Books. Available for preorder here.
Palmer, Alex. Whole Foods Attempts to Quell Boycott Cries. BrandWeek. Aug. 24. here.
A month and a half ago, Bill Carter of the Times charted its amazing rise.
In the three episodes measured so far this … season, “True Blood” has amassed viewer totals that any network, including broadcast networks, would be excited to own.
And today, here's what we heard from Robert Seidman on his TV By The Numbers blog:
[T]his week [True Blood] is up to 5.3 million. Last week [it] scored 4.46 million so the week-over-week growth is almost 20 percent. In two years of the blog, I’ve never seen any show with this sort of momentum.
This is good news for HBO. The last couple of years have been trying. The Chris Albrecht era that launched The Sopranos, Sex and the City and Six Feet Under is long gone (as is Albrecht). Showtime, a competitor, openly refers to HBO as HB-Over. HBO needed proof that it remains a vital force. It needed a hit and now it has one.
This is where an anthropologist perks up. If HBO can create something that flourishes in contemporary culture, it suggests that someone there gets our culture. A hit series is our chance to put an ear to the ground. How does the culture creator explain the hit he's created?
Alan Ball, the show creator, says the "elemental" reason True Blood works is this: "Women love the storytelling and the romance, and men love the sex and violence."
This can't be it. If only because it commits Ball and HBO to a clueless generalization. (I mean, have we not transcended these gender stereotypes? Josh Friedman said it was tough to get emotion and dialogue out of the female writers for The Sarah Connor Chronicles because "they just wanted to blow shit up." Especially, one guesses, stereotypes.)
Ball is more illuminating when he says the vampire literature that inspired him was "exciting and sexy and violent and romantic" and “authentically Southern, not cartoon Southern [with] elements of the Saturday matinee serial…‘Tobacco Road'…big gothic romance, and even social satire.”
This is better. But not perfect. It helps illuminate the form Ball gave True Blood. But not its content. I mean, why vampires? Why did this prove so successful? (We're not the only ones to wonder. When Michael Lombardo, the president of programming for HBO, first heard the proposal for the show, he said, “A vampire show? Really?”)
Fifty years ago, vampires were an embarrassing remainder of the Victorian era. Vampires were wan and overwrought, moody yet completely predictable, always on the verge of camp that was more likely to be funny "ha ha" than funny "Sontag." Vampires were too theatrical to be convincing, drama kings who'd somehow missed the memo on "cool." The full light of modernism drove vampires to their crypts. The rational, routinized world kept them there.
Til now. Now of course they're everywhere. Anne Rice gets a great deal of the credit. Take a bow Stephenie Meyer. Joss Whedon had the brilliant idea of dropping vampires into the sunniest of places (small town California) and the least dreadful of institutions (high school). Vampires now walked the land.
So what's the drill? Er, what's the thrill? I once did an interview with a vampire. And it's worth rehearsing here. I did the interview in Goth bar in Toronto in the 1990s. The "vampire" was in his late teens. He wore a velvet cloak, a ring with a little coffin on it, high Doc Martins (20 hole), black lipstick, eye liner, dyed black hair and a bottle of something red and viscous around his neck. Let's call him Jeff Brinsindun.
When I asked him to describe his appearance, Jeff said he was trying to look like an Edwardian gentlemen, and then he proceeded to call his look both "medieval" and "Victorian." In the course of the interview it became clear he did not know the meaning of the word "sensual." (He seemed to think it means "sensitive.") So the historical markers and even the stylistic adjectives had to be read as approximate. Jeff was proceeding with a certain semiotic latitude, evoking "another time" when men could dress extravagantly and with verve. And wear eye liner.
Jeff wanted to make something very clear for starters. He was not a vampire. And the bottle around his neck? Not blood, ok? Just so we're clear. And Jeff did not drink blood. He did not bite people. He did not expect to live forever. I took the news bravely. Not a vampire. Roger that.
No sooner had Jeff sworn off vampiric attributions, he began to invite them. He told me he thought it was "interesting" that he had never liked the light of day, that he would like to sleep in a coffin, that he wished he owned a Victorian house with velvet curtains. But he was not a vampire, okay? Okay.
The strategy was clear. Jeff was smart enough to see that any explicit claim to being a vampire must meet with ridicule. Better, then, to repudiate the claim up front and then sneak back into it by implication.
You could see why he was prepared to take the risk. There was clearly something rich and interesting about being a vampire. As Jeff described it, it was not so much a case of giddy dress-up as a great transformational vehicle. Dressed this way, Jeff got to be creatures, feel sensations and entertain scenarios otherwise inaccessible to him as a fast food clerk living in his parent's basement. Kitted out as a vampire, Jeff was more powerful, more jaded, more passionate, more enabled, more dangerous and more…more than he could otherwise have been.
The historical references are a little sloppy, I think, because Jeff (not his real name, but of course I knew you knew that) wanted access to the great sweep of history, to romantic figures of every period, to the powers of drama and darkness wherever they were extant. This is an experiential version of transmedia.
And then there is the real transmedia, those wellsprings of the vampire's tale, the folklore, the comic books, novels old and new, the TV shows, the various movies. This experiential modality is filling in and building out. The more the merrier, as far as Jeff is concerned. What does not strain our credulity makes him stronger. This is a genre that feeds on multivocality and intertexuality. All the noise in the signal turns out to be the stuff of the signal.
A lot has changed since I did this interview, a lot of vampires under the bridge, so to speak. Jeff was an early adopter, a brave experiment, one of the shock troops who made the world ready for vampires to follow. Much less danger of ridicule these days. No, these days, I expect, chicks dig it. Chances are Jeff must these days work hard to distinguish himself from all those poor, tortured, souls moping about out there.
Alan Ball says his vampire narrative is "exciting and sexy and violent and romantic." This is a way of saying it's versatile, that it conjoins things that doesn't always go together. Ball says there is even satire on offer. Which makes this a cultural invention that can do both engagement and disengagement at the same time. There's no cost. There's no trade off. There is, it turns out, nothing Aristotelian about vampires. They can do X and not-X with equal ease. Shape shifters all.
And still don't think this is it. We have to go a little further. And I am tempted by an outlandish notion that would take us much further. I think we are enamored of vampires because they are so much like celebrities. Vampires and celebrities are at once a mythic presence in our lives and, increasingly, a lot like us. We admire their powers, but vampire/celebrities are flawed and often tragic, and perhaps, on second thought, perhaps we are better to keep our distance. Vampires feed on us. They grow large on our admiration. But we feed them only to discover that we remain "little people," that what we give to them, they end up somehow taking from us.
I don't know. It's a bit strained. And I will leave it to my gifted readers to see if they can't supply intellectual triage and save this argument. I mean a robust version of this argument might explain why we care about vampires now. They are perhaps an extension, an exploration of our celebrity culture. Just a thought.
References
Auerbach, Nina. 1995. Our Vampires, Ourselves. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Carter, Bill. 2009. With a Little "True Blood," HBO is Reviving its Fortunes. The New York Times. July 12, 2009. here.
Jenkins, Henry. 2007. Transmedia Storytelling 101. Confessions of an Aca/Fan. March 22. here.
McCracken, Grant. 2008. Transformations: identity construction in contemporary culture. Bloomington: Indiana University Press. here.
Seidman, Robert. 2009. True bloody momentum for True Blood: 5.3 million and another record. TV By The Numbers. August 25. here.
Sontag, Susan. 2001. Against Interpretation: And Other Essays. New York: Picador.
Taylor, William C. and Polly LaBarre. 2006. Mavericks at Work. New York: HarperCollins. (For more on the Albrecht years at HBO)
A lot of people ask questions on TV. Most of them do it badly.
David Letterman keeps up the long standing tradition established by Johnny Carson. He is unapologetically incapable of curiosity. A stream of people pass the portals of Late Night and we are none the wiser. No good questions are asked. Good answers tend to be accidental.
While in Saratoga this weekend, Pam and I stayed with friends and got to see Costello's new talk show called Spectacle in which Costello does extended interviews with a remarkable diversity of musicians (from Lou Reed to Rufus Wainwright). It runs on Sundance.
Costello is intelligent and well informed. His questions are thoughtful and well chosen. He exhibits the humility required of a great interviewer. (He shows none of the reluctance to shut up and give over that tortures most Charlie Rose interviews these days.)
Five or ten minutes into this sort of thing and I had to put my hands on my knees and take deep breaths. I mean, it was dizzying. So much data. So much complexity. I actually had to pay attention. But once I got the hang of it, it was a great, spectacular, pleasure to behold.
I couldn't help wondering whether this is precisely the process by which popular culture gives up the adjective and becomes culture plain and simple. (And interesting to note that Elton John and David Furnish play originating producers here.)
Let's add Costello to our list of people to whom the CCO (Chief Culture Officer) will sometimes want access. This will usually be a matter of asking an assistant to fetch the appropriate episode of Spectacle. But for the executive with really deep pockets, a personal audience is perhaps not out of the question. Costello appears to be a citizen of all musical worlds. An hour in his presence could be a fantastically efficient way of solving certain CCO problems. (And of course it would be a story to dine out on indefinitely.)
References
Ryzik, Melena. 2008. Is it a Talk Show if the Host Sings? New York Times. November 28. here.
The mind boggles. Wal-mart apparently decided to copy Girl Scout cookies. C.V. Harguail (pictured) was the first one to raise the alarm and the reaction online and off has been tsunami-like.
What a public relations nightmare! A big corporation attacks the revenue stream of a distinguished not-for-profit community group…that represents decency, the American way and little girls? Oh, good one. It looked almost like Wal-Mart had decided on a potlatch destruction of goodwill and social capital. "Goodwill? Goodwill? We don't need no stinking goodwill." (As Bob Sutton points out, Wal-Mart is an organization that proves to be increasingly goodwill intensive. Someday its going to need goodwill the way aluminum smelting needs power.)
Now, surely several people inside the corporation took a look at this and thought, "Ok, this is a really bad idea." Nobody needs a Chief Culture Officer to spot an idea as bad as this. No, the reason Wal-Mart needs a CCO is because it needed someone inside the corporation with enough power to intercede.
Bad decisions in the corporate world take on a certain momentum. People start to say, "well, if lots of others think it's a good idea, who am I to object?" It's almost as if a consensus begins to form around the bad idea, and allowing it to pass more swiftly through the intestinal track on its way into the world. (Sorry about the metaphor.)
Wal-Mart needs someone in the C-suite that culturally sophisticated employees could reach out to. It needs someone in the C-Suite who can hear the whistle blowers blowing.
References
Harquail. C.V. 2009. Wal-Mart Knocks Off the Girls Scouts. Authentic Organizations. August 3. here.
McCracken, Grant. 2009. Chief Culture Officer. New York: Basic Books. Available for pre-order from Basic Books here.
Sutton, Bob. 2009. Wal-Mart and Girl Scout Cookies: Thin-Minty Gate. Work Matters. August 13. here.
Paul Snyderman was kind enough to write me a couple of days ago:
His question:
Grant,
Like so many other things in the marketing research world, I've gotten as many explanations of "co-creation" as there are people that I've asked.
Your blog item about the Snapple commercial notes the co-creation "peg" – which makes all the sense in the world. But, most of the explanations – and their associated methods – of achieving co-creation sound more like having the target customer "design" the promotion.
It seems that you're describing a process by which the target customer has such an authentic affinity for the advertising, that the ad has even greater effectiveness for the viewing target, and also the level of emotionality results in the target promoting the brand or the ad to others.
So, […] what's the deal?
My answer:
Paul, for me cocreation is a matter of creating something in the product that so appeals to the consumer that this consumer wants to pass it along to others for his or her own purposes. I see an ad I love, I sent it to you. I do something for the brand in question obviously, but I also do something for my own standing in the world. I am seen to be (or I hope I am seen to be) the kind of guy who can identify good stuff, who passes it along in the manner of an early adopter, who creates a little cultural capital for himself by associating myself with the ad.
At the base of this version of cocreation, I am an economic actor who is incented by the quality of the ad and or product to pass knowledge of same along to friends and strangers. My "fee;" an augmentation of my standing in the world.
There is a more elaborate argument here, one that talks about the fact that for many people especially more junior generations, the social network is crucial as a source of life partners, business partners, social standing. And these networks are mushroom like, hydraulic in a manner of speaking. These networks wither and die unless they are constantly fed, and when I send an ad through my network I sustain it.
What I hadn't guite seen before is that this ties back to the quality of the ad, and not in just some general sense, but in some more particular one. And this is why Google can't make ads. Only very talented advertising people can. And their source of value here comes from their mastery of the social and cultural details with which they make the ad richer, more engaging and more endearing.
As usual, everything comes back to this for me.
Best, Grant
Post script
There is an idea struggling to break free here, and I haven't quite identified it. Paul will no doubt do this for me. He's very smart. But I think it helps me see something about the agency model that can perhaps serve as part of its defense in this perilous times: that agency people, especially planners and creatives control an essential technology, a knowledge of the fine details, one might say, the secret details of social life and our culture, and that these fine and secret details are an essential part of the process by which the ad creates value for the brand and the client. Thoughts only. Thank you, Paul!
This month Town and Country shows Milla Jovovich sporting an Oscar de la Renta silk-satin gown with beaded strap ($4890.00).
Maxim shows her removing a tank top by Enza Costa (price unspecified).
It is one of those glorious moments when two parts of our extended, dispersive culture wrap around and touch. Glorious and rare. Surely, this is the first time anything featured in tony Town and Country has appeared in laddish Maxim. The wonder is that Jovovich has range enough to appear in both.
Are there any other actresses in Hollywood with this range? It's not acting range, exactly. Something more like cultural range or cultural mobility. Who, do you think…and why?
That's the narrow question. The broader questions: are we less siloed than we used to be. Does every actress have more mobility than before? Is something happening at Town & Country? Your thoughts, please.
My dad was a printer. Occasionally, he'd look at our newspaper with a "loupe," a magnifying glass. Printers use loupes to examine the dots that make up the letters on a page. At this level of detail, you can't see words, sentences, or headlines. Just dots.
I was reminded of loupes a lot when working in the museum world. This institution likes to look at the world very finely indeed. Curators corps spend their careers examining small bodies of evidence ever so carefully. The museum likes the loupe's eye view.
This spells trouble when the museum engages in public education. The museum curator wants to talk about subtle variations in the chair design in Concorde, Massachusetts in the period 1743 to 1760. The museum visitor wants a bigger picture. She wants to know how chairs tell the story of, say, children and child rearing in 18th century New England.
The loupe-eye view also spells trouble when it comes to finding someone to run the institution. To have authority within the institution, the Museum Director often comes from the curatorial ranks. Darn! We are asking the master of the fine detail to become the champion of the big picture. (Or we could adapt Isaiah Berlin's language: We are asking a hedgehog to become a fox.)
So it was a pleasant surprise to hear the new Director at the MET, Thomas Campbell, say the following.
Whether it's the grandeur of the Assyrian Reliefs room we have right above the end of the Great Hall, or the Temple of Dendur, or the dugout canoe we havee in our Arts of Africa, Oceania, and the Americas galleries–the second you start imagining what they were originally made for, what went on around them, it's exciting. You can practically here the sound of skin drums, or human sacrificies, or see the studiolo of a Renaissance connoisseur.
This is the bigger picture we need from a curator. This is the sort of thing that brings in the public. Yes, certainly, from the curatorial point of view, it errs in the direction of a romantic vision, inflaming the imagination, dramatizing the collection, embracing the cinematic. But exactly. As long as the MET is a public institution, it cannot please merely its curators and collecting elites. It must also speak to the rest of us.
References
Mead, Rebecca. 2009. Renaissance Man. The New Yorker. July 27, pp. 52-59, p. 57.