Fred Armisen is very good at making comedy, on SNL and more recently on Portlandia.
But he can’t always tell what’s going to work.
Here he is in an Entertainment Weekly interview making the puzzle clear.
Sometimes you do [a sketch] that’s good on paper and all the elements are there, but for some reason when you watch it, you can see … it doesn’t make it. We did this one where we’re both ambulance drivers. […] It seemed like such a good idea on paper; we were so excited about it. But it just didn’t work. Things that seem clear to us in our mind, sometimes when they’re on the screen you’re like, ”What is happening? What am I looking at?”
This is very interesting anthropologically. Most of the time, Armisen is right. A sketch works as well in practice as it did in concept. But every so often it just doesn’t work. Actually, it fails so badly Armisen ends up asking, “What am I looking at.” It seems pointless. Dead.
A magic ingredient is missing. The ghost in the machine. The god in the details. The spirit in the sketch. Or something. And that’s the puzzle: what’s that something?
Photo courtesy of Tammy Lo http://www.flickr.com/photos/tammylo/240569810/